Maintaining good oral hygiene is crucial for overall health, and a key part of that is cleaning between your teeth. But when it comes to interdental cleaning, which method reigns supreme: the traditional string floss or the modern water flosser? Are you struggling to decide which method truly gives you a cleaner mouth? This article provides an in-depth comparison of water flossers and string floss, supported by scientific evidence, to help you make the best choice for your unique needs.

At Smile Makers Dental Care, we believe in empowering our patients with the knowledge to make informed decisions about their oral health with brighter smile.

What are Water Flossers and String Floss?

Before diving into the comparison, let’s define what each tool is and how it works:

• String Floss: Traditional dental floss is a thin strand of nylon or plastic used to remove plaque and debris from between teeth and under the gum line. It requires manual dexterity to maneuver the floss effectively.
• Water Flosser: Also known as an oral irrigator, a water flosser uses a stream of pulsating water to dislodge food particles and plaque from hard-to-reach areas.

Effectiveness: Plaque and Debris Removal

One of the most important factors in choosing an interdental cleaning method is its effectiveness in removing plaque and debris.

• String Floss: String floss has been a long-standing recommendation by dentists for its ability to physically scrape plaque off tooth surfaces.
• Water Flossers: Studies have shown that water flossers can be highly effective at reducing plaque and gingivitis. According to MD Periodontics, water flossers can be 29% more effective at removing plaque than string floss. Additionally, Waterpik reports that water flossers may be up to 51% more effective than dental floss for reducing gingivitis.

However, research findings can sometimes vary.

A 2021 study published on the National Institutes of Health (NIH) concluded that water flossers were as efficient as regular floss in removing interdental plaque on single use.

It’s important to consider that effectiveness can depend on proper technique and individual circumstances.

Ease of Use and Convenience

• String Floss: String floss can be challenging to use, especially for individuals with limited dexterity, braces, or tight spaces between teeth.
• Water Flossers: Water flossers are generally easier to use, particularly for those with braces, dental work, or dexterity limitations. They can also be more convenient for people who find traditional flossing uncomfortable or time-consuming.

Pros and Cons of Each Method

Feature	String Floss	Water Flosser
Pros	Affordable	Easier to use, especially with braces or dental work
	Portable	Effective at reducing plaque and gingivitis
	Readily available	Can reach difficult areas
Cons	Can be difficult to use correctly	More expensive
	May cause gum irritation if used improperly	Requires a power source or batteries
	Time-consuming for some	Can be messy

Types of Water Flossers

Water flossers come in various types, each with its own advantages and disadvantages:

• Countertop Water Flossers: These are the most common type and offer a large water reservoir and multiple pressure settings.
• Cordless Water Flossers: Cordless models are portable and convenient for travel, but may have a smaller water reservoir and less powerful pressure.
• Shower Water Flossers: These attach to your showerhead for a convenient, mess-free flossing experience.
• Faucet Water Flossers: These attach directly to your faucet and offer a continuous water supply.

Flossing Techniques: How to Use Each Method Correctly

Proper technique is essential for both string floss and water flossers to maximize their effectiveness.

String Floss Technique:

1. Break off about 18 inches of floss.
2. Wrap most of the floss around your middle fingers, leaving a few inches to work with.
3. Gently guide the floss between your teeth using a sawing motion.
4. Curve the floss into a “C” shape around each tooth and slide it gently under the gum line.
5. Use a clean section of floss for each tooth.

Water Flosser Technique:

1. Fill the water reservoir with lukewarm water.
2. Select the appropriate pressure setting.
3. Place the tip of the water flosser in your mouth, aiming it at the gum line.
4. Turn on the water flosser and trace along the gum line, pausing briefly between each tooth.
5. Be sure to clean both the front and back of each tooth.

Cost Analysis

• String Floss: String floss is relatively inexpensive, with a cost of around $2-$5 per roll.
• Water Flossers: Water flossers have a higher initial cost, ranging from $30 to $100 or more. Replacement tips can cost $10-$20.

While the initial investment for a water flosser is higher, the long-term cost may be comparable when considering the ongoing expense of string floss.

Recommendations Based on Specific Needs

• Braces: Water flossers are often recommended for individuals with braces due to their ability to easily clean around brackets and wires.
• Gum Disease: Water flossers can be beneficial for people with gum disease as they can help reduce inflammation and remove bacteria from periodontal pockets.
• Sensitive Gums: Water flossers offer a gentler alternative to string floss for those with sensitive gums.

Expert Opinion

While both methods have their merits, consulting with a dental professional is always recommended.

Dr. Seema Shetty at Smile Makers Dental Care in Brampton, Ontario, emphasizes the importance of personalized oral hygiene plans.

“The best interdental cleaning method depends on individual needs and preferences,” says Dr. Shetty.

We work with our patients to determine the most effective and comfortable approach for maintaining their oral health.

Conclusion

Both water flossers and string floss can be effective tools for interdental cleaning. Water flossers offer ease of use and can be particularly beneficial for individuals with braces, dental work, or gum disease. String floss is a cost-effective and portable option. The best method depends on your individual needs, preferences, and oral health condition.

We encourage you to schedule a consultation with Smile Makers Dental Care to receive personalized recommendations for maintaining optimal oral health.

---

FAQs

1. Can a water flosser completely replace string floss?

While water flossers are effective, many dentists recommend using them in conjunction with string floss to ensure thorough cleaning.

2. Is water flossing messy?

Water flossing can be messy if not done carefully. It’s best to lean over the sink and start with a low-pressure setting to minimize splashing.

3. Are water flossers safe for everyone?

Water flossers are generally safe for most people. However, individuals with certain medical conditions should consult with their doctor before using one.